Easing Generational Tensions Around Investments

Older family members who rely on a steady dividend and younger ones counting on compounding often want very different things from a shared portfolio. Jamie Biddle, CEO of the duPont family’s Still Pond Capital, explains how his family works through those tensions with clear goals, outside facilitation and full transparency.

There are a lot of advantages to keeping family wealth together and investing it via a family office, rather than splitting it up. But there are also challenges. One common in many families can show up as a generational divide: Older family members want stable investments that provide income, whereas younger family members are looking for growth.

Jamie Biddle, CEO of Still Pond Capital, the family office of one branch of the duPont family, has seen this play out as an eighth-generation family member. The duPont family pays a quarterly dividend.

“That goes back to the history of the family, being owners of the DuPont Co. and General Motors,” Biddle says. “They had two large, public businesses, and those companies paid out a quarterly dividend. Even though we no longer own GM or DuPont stock other than in an index fund, we still pay a quarterly dividend, which flows primarily to the oldest living generation.”

This has the potential to create some generational tension.

- Advertisement -

“The people who are the beneficiaries of the distribution want stability in that payment stream. They don’t want a lot of volatility, because the dividend is based on the value of the assets of the family. It’s hard to manage your life when you don’t know what your income is going to be,” Biddle says. “Those who are younger and are not yet beneficiaries of the distribution are going to want compounding, because they want to make sure there is something left over for them when their day eventually comes.”

This also affects how much risk different family members are willing to take.

“You can get these generational tensions that tend to be young vs. old: Younger family members are much more comfortable with risk, because they have time to work their way out of problems,” Biddle says. “But if you’re 85 and you have a 50% drop in the market, the way we did in the global financial crisis, you may not have 16 years to recover, which is what it took back then to get back to breakeven. So, often, older family members don’t want to take that kind of risk.”

Families need to have a generational discussion to figure out how to resolve these conflicts.

“There’s no perfect answer, because the two are at odds with each other,” Biddle says. “You have to come to some kind of compromise. You need volatility to drive growth. If you’re going to try to increase your compounding, you’re going to increase your risk and your associated volatility. And if you want to dampen your volatility, then you’re going to reduce your ability to compound.”

Setting goals as a family

At Still Pond Capital, the family office board and the trust advisors for the family trusts have discussions with the family office that start with making sure everyone understands the family’s goal.

“That needs to be really clear, so that the office knows what it’s supposed to be doing,” Biddle says.

The specific goal will be different for each family.

“There are some entrepreneurs who don’t want their family to have the wealth at all, and they choose to give it away,” Biddle says. “For them, the goal is to give it away and not create generational wealth.”

Families that do want to create and pass on generational wealth need to start by agreeing on what that term means.

“If the goal is to create generational wealth — and I define that as maintaining purchasing power — then you have got to think long and hard about how you’re going to do that,” Biddle says. “It’s really hard to do, because it’s hard to compound your capital at a high enough rate without taking a lot of risk.”

These discussions may also include periodic reassessments of whether they want to invest together.

“Families are complicated,” Biddle says. “Families also generally like to avoid conflict, and money is a big conflict creator. So, the easiest solution is just to divide the pie and let everybody have their share and go their own way.”

However, there are drawbacks to this: Costs start to rise, and in some cases individual family members could have less access to the most sophisticated investments, such as venture capital or private equity, if the size of the capital is too small once it becomes fractured.

“You risk losing the opportunity to pick up that extra compounding because you’ve divided the pie into too small pieces,” Biddle says. There is also an increased chance that any one family member will make bad investment decisions.

“When the capital is together, there tends to be a greater collective focus on managing it and the oversight of it,” Biddle says. “So there’s less chance of taking an unforeseen risk, or of concentration risk if you’re managing it together as a group.”

‘Cultural glue’

The decision about whether and how to invest together may be motivated by more than pure financial calculations. A family office can provide a sort of “cultural glue” for a family, Biddle says, particularly for a family that has sold the operating business that provided them with a rallying point.

“When that company is gone, or you no longer hold an interest in it, what holds the family together?” Biddle says. “You can have some shared legacy, but as the generations go by, that gets further and further away.”

Managing investments together can create this same sort of cohesion.

“Having a pool of capital requires people to get together, to meet, to discuss, to plan, to organize, and I think that can help keep families together as well,” Biddle says. “So I think there are a lot of benefits to trying to keep the capital together, even though it becomes much more complicated sometimes.”

Creating a clear governance structure can help families build a family office and an investment program that will last. And families should not be afraid to see outside guidance when setting this up, Biddle says. Having a neutral third party lead the family discussions can help make sure everyone’s opinion is heard, for example.

“We got some professional help to think about the governance structure,” Biddle says. “It was really helpful — but creating the governance structure was the easy part. Where the real value came for us was having a third party to listen to all the stakeholders, gather their input, figure out where there was conflict and help facilitate discussion to get to agreement.”

This can also help with another crucial ingredient: transparency.

“Problems arise when there are unaddressed concerns that fester, and that often comes with a lack of transparency,” Biddle says. “People don’t understand what’s happening, where the money is, how much money they get — and when people don’t know, they get anxious. It’s better to be incredibly transparent about everything and then answer the questions and have the discussions.”

This can help ensure that everyone is satisfied, even if they didn’t get everything they wanted.

“There’s not likely to be a perfect solution that meets everyone’s needs,” Biddle says. “You do your best to meet the needs of most of the people while communicating why these decisions have been made. And you make sure the decisions are made by a representative group of the family who everyone understands is doing what they think is best for the collective whole.”

Still Pond Capital, LLC (“Still Pond”) is a Registered Investment Adviser (“RIA”) under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. Registration as an RIA does not imply any particular level of skill or training. All information contained herein reflects the opinions of Still Pond, is subject to change without notice, and is provided for informational purposes only. Nothing contained herein should be construed as legal, tax, or investment advice, or as a solicitation or offer to buy or sell any security or investment advisory service. Investment advisory services are available only to clients pursuant to a written investment advisory agreement and after receiving Still Pond’s Form ADV Parts 2A, 2B, and 3. Still Pond manages portfolios for individuals and institutions. All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. While Still Pond believes the information contained herein is from reliable sources, it does not warrant its accuracy or completeness and assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions.

About the Author

Margaret Steen

Margaret Steen is the editor of FO Pro, The Family Office Professional. Based in Silicon Valley, she has written for Family Business Magazine for more than 15 years.


Related Articles

FAMILY OFFICE + FAMILY BUSINESS

Sign up for FO PRO: The Family Office Professional. FO PRO connects family office leadership with the family.