As family offices become more professional, a key step for many is to set up a formal investment committee.
At the Shoebox Private Trust Company, that happened at the trust company’s inception, when the Shoebox Investment Committee was one of four committees set up supporting the board. It operates as a fiduciary body with exclusive oversight and responsibility for all investment activities carried out by PTC staff, says John Seckman, president of Shoebox Private Trust Company. This includes trust assets and corporate capital of the PTC.
The committee approves investment policies set by the staff, monitors performance and performs other key functions such as voting certain controlled company shares, Seckman says.
“Over time, the committee and Shoebox staff have developed a regular cadence of quarterly meetings that ensure the committee is performing all oversight duties appropriately and is up to speed with investment activity, third party managers and the staff,” Seckman says. “In practice, the committee and staff work together as a team to provide the best possible investment services to the family.”
This robust governance structure, including the investment committee, is typical of a more formalized, structured family office.
“As more offices have come online, there has been a trend towards more institutionalization. And as some of these family offices have aged, they have evolved, and they’re more likely to be professionally managed,” says Eric L. Johnson, U.S. family office tax leader for Deloitte LLP. “As you get to more of a professionally managed office, the governance structure evolves to become more formalized as well.”
Setting up an investment committee requires a number of decisions, starting with who will be on it. At Shoebox, for example, investment committee members are appointed by the board. The committee charter requires at least one independent member: someone with no family or company affiliation. Currently there are two independent members and one family member serving.
Whether the investment committee has a majority of outsiders or a majority of family members varies by family. Most investment committees include at least one outsider, often an investment professional with specific industry expertise, Johnson says.
Families face a lot of choices when setting up an investment committee beyond just who will be on it: where it sits in the family office governance structure, what authority it has, how often it meets and its role in the overall investment decision-making process, Johnson says.
Investment committees have varying levels of formality, starting with the process families use to choose committee members.
“On one end, it just so happens it’s the three senior generation family members. That’s just who it is,” Johnson says. “And on the other end, there’s a large family, maybe in the fifth, sixth or seventh generation, with dozens and dozens of family members. They actually have a formal governance process for applying for those roles. Then there is everything in between.”
Whether a family office has a formal, structured investment committee at all may depend on the size of the family and the stage of the family office.
Founder offices, with a single principal — particularly one with an investment background — may have that principal driving investment decisions and so won’t have an investment committee.
“But for offices that are serving, for example, G3, G4 and G5, it’s more of an endowment approach. They have robust asset allocation in various asset classes, and they’re managing the portfolio on behalf of a lot of different family members,” Johnson says. “An investment committee is almost always something that the families will adopt to help make decisions around the investments, both from an asset allocation standpoint and from a tactical one.”
What a professionalized family office and investment committee looks like may change in the future, with the adoption of AI. Some investment committees or family office boards are considering including an AI member that is part of the decision-making process, Johnson says.
“This isn’t the majority of offices, but it’s a trend that you might see in the future,” Johnson says. For now, though, it’s more common to see AI used as an analytical tool to help the committee members evaluate options and make decisions.
Even though committee governance is important, the structure of an investment committee should not overshadow its purpose.
“These committees can operate effectively under a variety of structures and levels of formality,” says Tom Lee, Pepin Family Office CEO. “So much depends on the investment under consideration. Don’t let the process get in the way!”
For example, Lee says, modeling is important, but it is no substitute for subject matter experts with industry-specific insights.
“We often reach beyond our core group of CPAs and advisors to seek these insights from relationships within a specific industry or engage consultation with an industry expert,” Lee says. “Many times, it’s hard to model intangibles of management and execution risk that can easily get overlooked without the input from the people who best know an industry and the skills and reputations of the individuals involved.”
Making sure the right voices are being heard may be more important than the formal structure.
“We believe collaboration leads to better decisions,” Lee says.

