Preparing for Family Leadership Transitions

More than half of family offices have no succession plan in place, according to a recent survey. Family office leaders and advisors share how defined roles, overlap periods, and outside work experience for the next generation help leadership handoffs go smoothly.

The transition from one family leader to the next in a family office can be an exciting time, with new opportunities for some family members, less demanding roles for others, and the potential for the family office to explore new directions. But like all family transitions, it can also be fraught with challenges — especially if the family is not planning and communicating clearly.

Andrew Bluestein’s family office recently went through a transition from first-generation to second-generation leadership, with the first generation family member moving into a board-only role. 

“Two things made it go smoothly,” says Bluestein, who is co-managing partner of Bluestein Ventures. “First, we defined roles and responsibilities across the family office, including the role of the family board, so everyone was aligned on how we intended to operate before the handoff. Second, we set up a full calendar year of meetings in advance, giving us structure around when the family board would engage.”

These are common themes among families that have been through successful family leadership transitions in a family office: The family needs to understand and agree on who has what responsibilities, and the transition should be carefully planned, with some overlap between leaders if possible. 

- Advertisement -

Unlike professional staff, who are likely to move on to a different employer when they leave, family members will still be around — making gradual transitions easier. 

This was the case for Joe Tracy’s family when his brother recently stepped off the board as chair and Tracy took over. 

“He is still involved in the family office since he chairs two of our other businesses,” says Tracy, who is CEO of Dot Family Holdings. In recent years, they have hired a non-family CFO and a new vice president of business development. “Keeping family members around part time as they exit larger roles has helped ensure smooth transitions in our largest business and our family office.”

Although having a clear plan is key to making the transition go smoothly, many family offices have not prepared. A survey by RSM found that 55% of family offices do not have a succession plan in place. Of those that do have a plan, only 37% have a formal written plan. The rest have plans that are less well defined: an incomplete plan that is still under development (34%), a verbally agreed-upon plan (20%), or an informal plan (9%). 

In addition to having a plan for a specific transition, many families also find it useful to agree on more general policies about family office leadership. One question these policies can answer: what qualifications family members need to take on leadership roles in the family office.

“Many families have found that a good practice is rather than having those younger execs work directly for the family office as their first place of employment, they should go out and make their mark elsewhere — have people outside the family business train them,” says Eric L. Johnson, U.S. family office tax leader for Deloitte LLP. “Working for a third party will better discipline them, and then they can learn something — whether it’s real estate or private equity — and bring those skill sets back to the office.”

Clear policies are helping the Vermeer Family Office lay the groundwork for an upcoming transition. 

“We are currently preparing for a leadership transition within the family’s Ownership Council,” says Aaron Smith, senior family office manager at the Vermeer Family Office. “A recently updated Ownership Council Chair transition policy has been instrumental in that process, with consistent communication around the application process, timeline, and role expectations, giving both the Council and broader family time to prepare for this significant change.”

Smith says this will be a gradual transition, one they are modeling on past successful leadership handoffs.

“The policy also includes a planned overlap year, which has proven effective in the past by enabling the incoming leader to transition smoothly while recognizing the contributions of the outgoing chair,” Smith says. 

The specifics of the timing and the policies needed will vary depending on the family.

“Family transitions can be sometimes easy and sometimes difficult, depending on the family makeup,” Johnson says. 

He says families that have an operating business in which family members are involved may have an easier time recruiting family leaders to the family office.

“In a family office environment where most of the office’s activities are around an operating business, often family members grow up through that operating business and then can make a really successful transition to the family office, because they understand the business so well,” Johnson says. “When that environment isn’t there, and the family office has been set up for investment purposes, there isn’t as easy a framework for getting those family leaders involved.”

This may mean it takes more work for a family without an operating business to identify its next family office leader and create a strong transition plan. But the work of defining responsibilities and communicating the plan to the family will be key.

“Clarity matters more than speed,” Bluestein says. “Writing down roles and decision rights, and getting genuine buy-in on them before the transition, is what makes the difference.”

About the Author

Margaret Steen

Margaret Steen is the editor of FO Pro, The Family Office Professional. Based in Silicon Valley, she has written for Family Business Magazine for more than 15 years.


Related Articles

FAMILY OFFICE + FAMILY BUSINESS

Sign up for FO PRO: The Family Office Professional. FO PRO connects family office leadership with the family.