At Elmwood Management, investment decisions are made by a majority-independent investment committee. At Webb & O’Neill Capital, the investment committee recently doubled from one to two family members. And at Dot Family Holdings, CEO Joe Tracy leads an investment committee with a majority of family members.
“I chair the committee, but it includes our family office CFO and five other family members from the second and third generations,” Tracy says. “Each serves a three-year term.”
There may be as many variations on investments committees as there are family offices. Investment committees work to accomplish the investment goals of the family office, which are often laid out in an investment policy statement. In some families, the investment committee also helps communicate with the broader family about how the family’s investments are doing.
An investment committee is particularly critical when the family office is managing jointly owned assets across multiple family members, says Janet Arzt of Parere Advisory.
Focus on family members
Investment committees generally have a majority of family members, and there is often overlap in membership with other governing bodies, such as the family office board or the family council, Arzt says.
“A lot of family members want to know what’s in the portfolio and why they’re making investment decisions, so a lot of the family members will raise their hand for this,” Arzt says.
Family members are generally chosen for the investment committee based on their expertise — someone who worked on Wall Street, for example, or for a private equity or venture fund.
That’s the case with Celine Fitzgerald’s family.
“My husband recently joined Webb & O’Neill Capital as chief investment officer. With his extensive background in finance, he and my dad will form the formal committee,” says Fitzgerald, a G3 family member at Webb & O’Neill Capital. “While my dad has executed his role well in the past, bringing in a new perspective with a formalized policy will allow us to be more aggressive and diversify.
Bringing in outside expertise
For a number of reasons, families may decide to include non-family members on the investment committee.
The Elmwood Management investment committee, which has final decision rights on investments, includes the CEO of the family’s operating company, two family office professionals, and a university endowment professional.
“This is a great mix of individuals and backgrounds: some that look like us, some are examples of what we would like to be someday (one is much larger than us), and the endowment person, who has a very different perspective on investment given their mandates are different than what a typical family office would be,” says Austin Herschend, managing director of Elmwood Management. “Our CEO of the operating business is a great link back to the operating business and gets to see what the family is feeling and thinking about, investment wise, outside of largest family-held asset.”
Having the investment committee set up this way is also a good way to ensure all the entities are communicating on things that could be impacting both the operating business and investment business, Herschend says. And the committee is an excellent pipeline for deals.
For family offices with a smaller liquid portfolio, where hiring a full-time chief investment officer may not be feasible, adding an experienced professional to the investment committee is a good way to get outside expertise.
“They can bring in expertise from professionals with investment experience without having them commit to a full-time, senior employee role,” Arzt says.
Even in larger family offices, outsiders who join the investment committee can bring expertise on specific asset classes.
“If a family has a specific interest in investing in real estate, it probably makes sense for someone on the committee to come from a real estate private equity firm, for instance — to help guide them on decisions and the market,” Arzt says.
Some families have hedge fund managers on their investment committee, for example, because they want to invest in emerging markets or new asset classes.
“They also may want to be on the cutting edge of markets and asset allocation,” Arzt says. “If families want to start diversifying into different asset classes, then they should consider having someone from those asset classes sit on the committee to help them think about how to approach it.”
Making the investment committee work
Decisions about who will be on the investment committee should be made alongside other key decisions.
For example, Arzt notes that whenever an outsider is brought onto the investment committee, it’s important to consider any possible conflicts and how to avoid them.
It can also be a good idea for a newly formed family office to put an investment committee in place before hiring the office’s investment professionals.
“Sometimes without that governance framework, you can drop investment professionals into these seats, and it’s unclear who’s involved, or how much discretion they have over the portfolio, and who they are reporting into to make those decisions,” Arzt says.
To avoid problems like this, it’s important to think about the overall decision-making framework from the beginning — and to answer the question: What is the family trying to accomplish strategically through the family office?
“It could be maintaining some level of distributions for family members. It could be compounding wealth through investments in certain asset classes. It could be avoiding some asset classes that are conflicting with the family’s values,” Arzt says. “Usually there are some guardrails that are in place that they will use to inform the recommendations.”

